Skip to main content
of the subject project, Learned Counsel submitted that in order to ensure that the Government achieved value for money in any subsequent procurement, the 1stInterested Party carried out extensive review of the project and the process to determine the best way forward, including carrying out consultation with key stakeholders and sought and obtained approval to use a Specially Permitted Procurement Procedure (herein referred to as the “SPP”) under section 92 of the Act as read with Regulation 64(1)(a) of the Public Procurement and Disposal Regulations, 2006 (the Regulations). It was stated that the approval was granted by the Public Procurement Oversight Authority (PPOA) in a letter dated 29 th October 2013 and the SPP was incorporated in the tender documents. Clause 29 of the Tender Data Sheet included processes not taken in a normal procurement such as competitive bidding and the submission of Best and Final Offers (BAFO) in line with Regulation 31(7) of the Regulations which allow procuring entities to use creative approaches to enhance efficiency of the procurement process and project implementation. To the 1 Interested Party, this is one of the very few public procurement projects in Kenya in which such st procedures have been adopted. 32. According to the 1st Interested Party, the yardstick used in adjudicating disputes arising out of an SPP would not be the same as those applied in conventional procurements-a fact the Respondent failed to consider. The 1st Interested Party denied that it disregarded the provisions of the law and averred that the SPP incorporated in the tender document adhered to the letter and spirit of the Act and the Regulations since the SPP had been reviewed by PPOA before the tender process begun. 33. It was the 1st Interested Party’s position that it acted timeously in the tender process and communicated promptly to the bidders of all necessary steps which process saw savings of a total of Kshs. 8,025,151,216.25 in the second tender as compared to the first tender. 34. The 1st interested party clarified that the bidding was done in 3 categories: Lot 1 (Laptops for learners and Laptops for teachers); Lot 2; (Printers) and Lot 3; (Projectors) and that the Ex parte Applicant was the successful bidder for Lot 1, having the least evaluated price after the competitive negotiations and the evaluation of the BAFOs pursuant to the procedure established for purposes of the SPP. To the 1st Interested Party, it went to great lengths to protect taxpayer’s money by investing a lot of time and care into the tender process as is evident on the due diligence exercise carried out. 35. In its view, the Board was guilty of unreasonable exercise of power and irrationality, because its decision defies logic such that no sensible person or body could have reached the same decision considering the facts in the case and applicable law and relied on Associated Provincial Picture Houses Ltd. vs. Wednesbury Corporation [1948] 1 KB 223. 36. Further and based on De Smith, Woolf and Jowell: Judicial Review of Administrative Action,7th Edition at paragraph 11-036 on page 602 it was contended that the decision was irrational. 37. In support of the interested party’s case, it was submitted that the Respondent purported to exercise the powers conferred on it by the Act in reaching its finding and annulling the award of the tender by the 1st Interested Party to the Applicant. The 1st interested party however contended based on the decision of Nyamu, J (as he then was) in Keroche Industries Limited vs. Kenya Revenue Authority [2007] KLR 240 that statutory powers and duty must be exercised and performed reasonably. Based on R vs. Public Procurement And Administrative Board Ex-Parte Zhongman Petroleum & Natural Gas Group Company Ltd [2010] eKLR which followed Anisminic vs. Foreign Comp. Comm. (H.L.) [1969] 147, it was contended that an

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents