Skip to main content
relation to any goods in respect of which it is registered and in such manner as to render the use of the mark likely to be taken as being use of a trade mark. Mr. Mpanga, counsel for the Plaintiff, submitted and I so find that the toothbrushes imported into Uganda by the defendant were labelled or branded in such a way as to make any person believe that they are the products or toothbrushes of the Plaintiff Company. The Plaintiffs packet at the back has the words “Manufactured by Nice House of Plastics---”. The Defendants packet has similar statement at the back. Both blister packs in the inside have the Plaintiff‟s name “NICE HOUSE OF PLASTICS LTD”. The packets are of the same colour. Save for the minor differences pointed out by the Plaintiff‟s Company Secretary, who by virtue of her employment with the Plaintiff Company was very familiar with the Plaintiff‟s product and get-up, there are a number of striking similarities in the get – up of the two products. The Plaintiff‟s evidence clearly show that the Defendant had no other reason of importing into Uganda toothbrushes labelled and packed as NICE TOOTHRUSH and NICE respectively. The Defendant was using the Plaintiff‟s trademarks namely NICE and NICE TOOTHBRUSH as marks of origin of the imported toothbrushes. I therefore find that the Plaintiff has proved that the Defendants usage of the Plaintiff‟s said trademarks amounted to infringement of its trademarks by the Defendant. Issue No. 3. Whether the Defendants action in manner in which he packed and labelled the toothbrushes imported into Uganda amounts to passing off of the Plaintiff‟s trademarks and product get – up. In Abercrombie & Kent Ltd v/s Abercrombie & Kent (U) Ltd [1997 – 2001 UCL 157 as to the cause of action of passing-off C.K Byamugisha J. (as she then was) stated: “The legal basis for an action of passing off is that it is wrong for the Defendant to represent, for trading proposes, that his/her goods on the market or the business is that of the Plaintiff. It is immaterial whether the representation made is effected by direct statements or by using the badges or get ��� up by which the goods or business of the Plaintiff are known by the ordinary consumers”. In Keerly‟s Law of Trade Mark at page 203 it is stated thus:“The principle of law may be very plainly stated, that nobody has a right to represent his goods as the goods of somebody else. How far the use of particular words, signs or pictures, does or does not come up to the proposition enunciated in each particular 7

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents