Skip to main content
showing how the 1st Interested Party breached the Act and the Regulations, by reference to specific provisions. 48. In its view, distinction between value-added services and additional services was submitted on by the 1st Interested Party in exact terms as those by the Ex parte Applicant. Whereas value added services were to be offered free of charge, additional services were all the services outside the unit cost of the devices being procured which services were necessary for the operationalisation and functioning of the devices. Value added services were extra services sought by the 1 st Interested Party through competitive negotiation based on the negotiation template incorporated in the BAFOs. The value added services aspect greatly enhanced value for money in this procurement proceeding, as part of SPP. The Respondent, it was submitted failed to distinguish between additional services and value added services, hence, the unreasonable decision. The only difference in the manner in which the bidders set out the prices was that the additional services were quoted separately in the Price Schedule as was done by the 3 rd Interested Party, or they were deemed incorporated in a separate quote in the Price Schedule as was done by the 2nd Interested Party, or distinguished and itemized to give a clear breakdown of what constituted the services being charged as was done by the Applicant. Therefore, the Respondent statement in their ruling that “Mr. Ajay from the interested party confirmed that these items had been provided for in the original tender document and amounted to a repetition” is erroneous and demonstrated the failure by the Respondent to make the correct distinction between the two aspects of the bid. The fact that the Applicant gave that breakdown in a schedule annexed to the tender document is immaterial, especially since the annexure was properly referred to in the Standard Form of Contract as well as the Price Schedule. For the Board to find that the prices set out in the annexure constituted an “astronomical inclusion…“was unreasonable. All the three bidders’ Price Schedules were different but all the bidders were treated in the same manner. Had the Respondent properly reviewed the documents, it would have seen that the Applicant’s Price Schedule did not change the substance of the tender and that there was no alteration of price. As recognized by Section 64(2) (a) of the Act, minor deviations that do not materially depart from the requirements set out in the tender documents are excusable. The itemization of the Applicant's additional services is a minor deviation which did not materially depart from the requirements of the tender. The 1 st interested party therefore averred that it was unreasonable for the Respondent, having claimed to have reviewed the documents before it, to have concluded that the Applicant herein charged for services that should have been offered for free and for which the other bidders were not charging when the documents showed otherwise. 49. The conclusion by the Respondent that the Applicant was awarded at a price higher than that contained in the form of tender as accounted at BAFO was, according to the interested party; in contravention of the Act and the regulations thereunder as well as the tender document; was simplistic and showed a lack of understanding of the Act and its regulations. 50. The Board in its view took into account irrelevant considerations, and failed to take into account relevant considerations. In addition, the Board’s finding that the 1st Interested Party had failed to file affidavits which was part of the basis in finding against the 1st Interested Party, it was submitted was misconceived since all the documents containing all the facts relied upon by the 1st Interested Party in setting out its case to the Board had been submitted to the Board. Further, it was irrelevant to consider standard procurement procedures since the import of Section 92 of the Act is that the SPP is to have its own procedure as prescribed. This was the first time that a procurement procedure involving competitive negotiation was employed successfully. In support of this submission the interested party relied on Warsame, J’s (as he then

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents