Skip to main content
copyright in his work. This is that there will be occasions when it is in the public interest not merely that information should be published, but that the public should be told the very words used by a person, notwithstanding that the author enjoys copyright in them. Furthermore they reached the conclusion that in rare circumstances the right of freedom of expression would come into conflict with the protection afforded by the Copyright Act, notwithstanding the express exceptions to be found there under. In the circumstances they felt bound to apply the Copyright Act in a manner that accommodates the right to freedom of expression and considered the specific circumstances to see whether the defence of "public interest" would be availed to the Defendant. Counsel further relied on a summary of the law by Laddie, Prescott and Victoria, "The Modern Law of Copyright and Designs". In the textbook there is a definition of what amounts to fair dealing. The first important factor is whether the alleged fair dealing is in fact commercially competing with the proprietor‘s exploitation of the copyright work, a substitute for the probable purchase of authorised copies. If it is, the fair dealing defence would fail. On the other hand if there is a moderate taking and there are no special adverse factors, the defence is likely to succeed especially if the Defendant‘s additional purpose is to right a wrong, to ventilate an honest grievance, to engage in political controversy and so on. The second most important factor is whether the work has already been published or otherwise exposed to the public. If it has not, where the material has been obtained by breach of confidence or other mean or underhand dealings, the court would be reluctant to say that this is fair. It may be fair for purposes of legitimate public controversy to make use of "leaked" information. Another important factor is the amount and importance of the work that has been taken. Although it is permissible to take a substantial part of the work, in some circumstances the taking of an excessive amount or the taking of even a small amount if on a regular basis would negative fair dealing. I have carefully considered the principles and I have come to the conclusion that the cases are irrelevant in considering the defence of "public interest". This is because in the first place the public interest is considered in the context of the use of the copyright work. In other words where it is a criticism of the work, where it is an exposure of the work for other legitimate reasons, where the work is leaked in the public interest etc, it would be a defence to the use of the work by the Defendant. Secondly the case before the court does not involve conflicting interests between freedom of expression and the freedom of press against the right to copyright. In the Ashdown case information that was leaked was found to have violated the applicant's copyright. The Defendant is not a reporter or involved in the business of reporting news to the public and the question of freedom of press cannot be considered. As far as its campaign is concerned, there is no judicial precedent to the effect that the use of copyrighted work could be permitted for a campaign in the public interest without consent of the owner of the copyright. I have duly considered public interest as discussed by David Bainbridge on "Intellectual Property" 6th Edition between pages 190 and 193. He writes that 'public interest' is a nebulous

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents