Skip to main content
whether the Defendant‘s advertisement jingle was excusable as something made in the public interest. Starting with the question of public interest the Defendants Counsel relied on the case of Advocates Coalition for Development and Environment versus Attorney General and another High Court Miscellaneous Cause No 0100 of 2004. The applicant, a nongovernmental organisation, filed an application under article 41 (1) and 15 (1) and (2) of the Constitution of the Republic of Uganda for orders and declarations that the granting of a permit to Kakira Sugar Works by the first respondent contravened article 39 and 237 of the Constitution the Republic of Uganda and section 43 of the Land Act. Secondly they sought declarations that the de-gazetting of the forest reserve was in violation of the applicant's right to a clean and healthy environment. Several other remedies/declarations were sought but I do not need to refer to them for purposes of considering the question of "public interest" raised by the Defendant‘s Counsel. The specific holding that the Defendant‘s Counsel relied upon was that the forest reserve in question was for the good of the people and was held in trust for the people of Uganda and had to be protected for the common good of citizens. Secondly that the government had no authority to lease out or otherwise alienate it. The court found that a permit was granted to Messieurs Kakira Sugar Works Ltd amid protests from local communities which depended on the reserve for their livelihood through Agro - forestry and, source of water, fuel and other forms of sustainability. The grant of the permit was therefore in breach of the "public doctrine". I do not clearly see how this authority is relevant to the Defendant‘s defence of "public interest". The way I understand it is that the Defendant asserts that it used the Plaintiff‘s song "let's go green" in the public interest efforts of conserving Namanve forest reserve. It is not in dispute that efforts to conserve Namanve forest would be in the public interest as far as environmental conservation is concerned. However whether or not it is in the public interest has nothing to do with whether the Plaintiff's song "let's go green" could be used. The issue is whether a person who acts in public interest can use copyrighted works in a public interest drive. In the case of Hon. Paddy Ashdown versus the Telegraph Group Limited Case No A3/2001/0213 cited as [2001] EWCA Civ 1142 being an appeal to the Supreme Court of Judicature Court of Appeal (Civil Division) from the Queen's Bench Division/Chancery Division, the issue concerned a suit brought against the publication of confidential information. The court attempted to balance between two conflicting rights namely the right to copyright as well as the right to freedom of expression. The court further considered restrictions on copyright including the fair dealing exception for the purpose of reporting current events and which does not infringe any copyright in the work. Particularly the court considered the fact that the defence for breach of copyright can be mounted on the basis of "public interest". First of all the court found that it was not a statutory defence but a common law defence. Specifically section 171 (3) of the Copyright Act of the UK provides that nothing in that part of the Act affects any rule of law preventing or restricting the enforcement of copyright, on grounds of public interest or otherwise. The Plaintiff was granted an injunction restraining any further infringement of the

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents