Skip to main content
I will consider the provisions of section 15 of the Copyright and Neighbouring Rights Act as well as case law on what amounts to substantial use. Every statute has to be interpreted on the basis of its own language and unless there is doubt as to the meaning of a specific provision, it should be interpreted as it is. Contextual interpretation only comes in where the meaning in a particular section cannot be discerned from the wording used. However in this particular case no one has pointed out any controversy in the meaning of section 15 of the Copyright and Neighbouring Rights Act. I would therefore deal with the extensive subsections on the question of fair use of works protected by Copyright. Section 15 (1) of the Act provides that fair use of the protected work in its original language or in a translation shall not be an infringement of the right of the author and shall not require the consent of the owner of the copyright in several situations which are listed under the subsection and which will be considered in turn. In subsection (a) it is fair use where "the production, translation, adaptation, arrangement or other transformation of the work is for private personal use only;" in this case it has not been suggested that the use of the Plaintiffs work was for private personal use only since it was used in an advertisement for a public campaign section 15 (1) (a) of the Copyright and Neighbouring Rights Act does not apply to the Plaintiff‘s case or the Defendant‘s defence. Subsection (b) of section 15 of the Act provides that "a quotation from the published work is used in another work, including a quotation from a newspaper or periodical in the form of press summary, where – (i) the quotation is compatible with fair practice; and (ii) the extent of the quotation does not exceed what is justified for the purpose of the work in which the quotation is used, and (iii) acknowledgement is given to the work from which the quotation is made." In this particular case it cannot be concluded that there was any quotation from the published work. Under section 2 of the Copyright and Neighbouring Rights Act, 2006, the word "publication" means the lawful reproduction of all work or of an audiovisual or audiovisual sound recording, fixation or of sound recording for availability to the public; and includes public performances and making available of the work on the Internet. Whereas the music was part of an advertisement which may be defined as the publication, the word "published" means that the work is made available to the public in a reasonable quantity for sale, rental, public lending or for other transfer of ownership or possession of the copies. I do not agree that there was a quotation of the published work by playing the Plaintiff's song in the background of the advertisement jingle. The Plaintiff song was played in the background and comes out clearly at the beginning and at the end of the advertisement jingle. There was no quotation and therefore the provisions of section 15 (1) (b) of the Copyright and Neighbouring Rights Act does not apply to the Defendants defence of fair use. As far as subsection (c) of section 15 (1) of the Act is concerned it provides that: "a published work is used for teaching purposes to the extent justified for the purpose by way of illustration in

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents