Skip to main content
party, the 2nd Interested Party tried to conceal the fact that it used ODMs by altering the document it placed before the Board, but the Respondent did not to act on this. The contention by the 2nd Interested Party which was accepted by the Respondent that an ISO Certificate did not constitute the Ex parte Applicant an OEM is incorrect as it fails to acknowledge the context in which the certificate was produced. To it, the said certificate is only one of several items of evidence showing that the Applicant was an OEM and is certainly not the only document that was considered by the 1 st Interested Party in reaching the conclusion that the Applicant was duly qualified to bid for the tender. The decision of the Respondent was also unreasonable in that it found that the Applicant herein was not an OEM and yet the Applicant had demonstrated use of the same ODMs contracted by the 2ndInterested Party. 40. On Joint Venture, the 1st Interested Party submitted that a substantial part of the decision reached by the Respondent is hinged upon the finding that the Applicant did not bid as a joint venture. Clause 3.1 of the Instruction to Tenders (ITT) was however unequivocal in granting the eligible bidders an option to bid as either under an already established joint venture or consortium or to show the formal intent to enter into a joint venture which view is further buttressed by other clauses in the tender document. Apart from that there was in the tender documents submitted to the Board, the Ex parte Applicant’s formal intent to enter into a joint venture arrangement as evident from the Memorandum of Understanding between the Applicant and its proposed Joint Venture Partner. Therefore the respondent’s finding that it had examined the original Tender documents and had found “no evidence to prove that the Interested Party participated in this Tender as part of a consortium or a joint venture with any other company”was, erroneous, irrational and unreasonable. 41. To the 1st interested party, the Respondent ignored all those facts which were both cited in the submissions before it and also present in the documents submitted to it. The finding that the applicant bid as a single entity was wholly unfounded and therefore unreasonable and irrational. From the Respondent’s decision, it selectively reviewed the tender documents. For instance, the Respondent made reference to the Due Diligence Report submitted by the First Interested Party but failed to consider the information obtained by the 1st Interested Party on the existence of Memorandum of Understanding between the Applicant and its joint venture partner. 42. The 1st interested party explained that the threshold for experience by the bidders for purposes of the tender was two-fold according to the tender documents. First, the bidders had to show that they had at least 5 years’ experience in providing services and solutions similar to those required by the tender and secondly, that they had engaged in at least three contracts of at least the equivalent of Kshs. 500 million each. In its view, as the Ex parte Applicant demonstrated both these aspects of its experience and that of its joint venture partner in the tender documents it submitted, in finding that the Ex parte Applicant did not have the requisite experience, the Respondent took into account only the ISO certification of the Ex parte Applicant and erroneously stated that the 1st Interested Party had cited the said certification as the only evidence of experience considered in determining whether the Applicant was qualified to bid. Yet the tender documents submitted by the Applicant clearly showed that the Applicant and its joint venture partner had combined experience of much more than the average 5 years required. While the TDS was clear that the ISO Certificate was one of the documents required to be submitted, it did not specify the period in respect of which the ISO Certificate should have been issued to the bidder. An ISO Certificate, it was contended is a certification of quality of the goods or services provided and the efficiency of an organization as at the time of issue.

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents