Skip to main content
Secondly having determined the question of whether the Defendant's action fell within the 'fair use' exception, what remains to be concluded is whether the Defendant infringed the Plaintiff‘s copyright. Under section 46 of the Copyright and Neighbouring Rights Act it is stipulated that infringement of Copyright or neighbouring right occurs where without a valid transfer, licence, assignment or other authorisation under the Act, a person deals with any work or performance contrary to the permitted free use. In this case I have established that there was no permitted free use and that the Defendant‘s use does not fall within the fair use exception. There was no valid transfer, licence, assignment or authorisation of the Defendant by the Plaintiff. I have duly listened to the exhibited CD containing both the song "let's go green" and the advertisement jingle. It is quite clear that the structure of the song is the same. It starts with the ―let's go green‖ song and an appeal for people to take action on the environment. The theme of this song is about calling people to change so that wetlands, forests and grasslands etc are not destroyed by "going green". It is apparent that the Defendant selected this song because it was appropriate for its campaign to save Namanve Forest. The advertisement jingle begins with the same theme of "let's go green" as embodied in the song and continues with a jingle about the fact that the remaining part of Namanve Forest is being destroyed by politicians who are illegality demarcating it into plots at the pretext of resettling slum dwellers. It asked the public whether they were aware of what was happening and appeals to members of the public to reject the illegal takeover of public resources without following the right de-gazetting processes. The public is further informed that it was authorised by the Minister of Water and Environment but had not been approved by Parliament and alternative land to nurture an alternative Forest was not provided for. Finally the public is informed that it is their obligation to demand that the illegal giveaway of Namanve Forest is stopped. They call upon Parliament to investigate the matter and bring those responsible to book. Finally it is indicated in the advertisement jingle that the message was brought by the Anticorruption Coalition Uganda (the Defendant). It ends with the Plaintiff's song "let's go green". While the verbal messages are being given, the music keeps on playing in the background the whole time. What happened is that the volume was only tuned down to make the message audible and then increased again to end with the song "let's go green". The Plaintiff's song "let's go green" was used for the entire advertisement. It was not used accidentally or incidentally but deliberately because of its theme. The Defendant just incorporated the Plaintiff's song "let's go green" as part of its advertisement jingle and thereby infringed the Copyright of the Plaintiff under section 46 (1) of the Copyright and Neighbouring Rights Act. I have secondly considered section 46 (2) of the Copyright and Neighbouring Rights Act which provides that the use of the piece of work in a manner prejudicial to the honour or reputation of the author shall be deemed an infringement of the right of the author. It is the Plaintiff's case that the Defendant‘s use put her on a collision course with officials of government. The Defendant‘s Counsel attacked the testimony of the Plaintiff on the ground that there was insufficient evidence to support her contention that she suffered humiliation and embarrassment and the advertisement

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents